News

‘Reward for failure:’ Damehood awarded to woman who quit post due to collapse of rape trials

Former director of public prosecutions Dame Alison Saunders, whose damehood was criticised, will be awarded the honour by the Princess Royal. It has lead to sharp criticism of the honours system.

Dame Alison, ex-head of the Crown Prosecution Service, was made a Dame Commander of the Order of the Bath for services to criminal justice in the 2019 New Year Honours list.

She quit her post in 2018 after a series of controversies including the collapse of a series of rape trials due to the late disclosure of evidence, leading to a review of every rape case in the country.

As a result, 47 cases were halted.

Failure

The damehood was labelled a “reward for failure” but at the time Dame Alison defended her honour in an interview with The Times newspaper, saying it was for “30 years of public service”.

During the St James’s Palace investiture ceremony, Anne will also award an MBE to former Premier League footballer Francis Benali, who has raised a million pounds for cancer victims.

The ex-Southampton Football Club defender will receive the honour for services to cancer patients after enduring a number of fundraising challenges, including completing seven Ironman-distance triathlons over seven days, in aid of the charity Cancer Research.

Claire Horton, former chief executive of Battersea Dogs and Cats Home, will be made a CBE for services to animal welfare.

She spent more than 10 years at the leading charity before leaving to take up the role of director general with the Commonwealth War Graves Commission.

There was also controversy over former Conservative leader Iain Duncan Smith’s knighthood.

The MP was responsible for the government’s controversial Universal Credit welfare reforms.

Labour MP Lisa Nandy said the honour was a reward for a “legacy of cruelty and failure”.

Related: PMQs : ‘They jabber’ says PM – to cheers – after dodging questions why virtually no rape cases end in conviction

Joe Mellor

Head of Content

Published by